My 2010 VW POLO TSI GT DSG

My Mk5 Polo, or to use its full grandiose title, Polo TSI GT DSG Car of the year edition. Though it only says Polo TSI on the back. GT is a spec level in Sweden, I believe the UK equivalent would be SEL. The Car of the year edition was a limited run model to celebrate winning COTY and was 1.2 TSI GT Polo with DSG box and RCD310 satnav system. It was the only way to get a 1.2 TSI Polo in Sweden in 2010 and so I bought one.
I bought it as an economical commuter car and a counter point to my weekend toy, a 1988 535i. It replaced a 2007 320i and this should be kept in mind as it colours my view of the Polo.

I feel that the Polo Mk5 is, alongside the Jetta 6, one of the best looking cars VW have ever produced. But we are not here to discuss styling…
The two most interesting features of this car are the TSI engine and DSG box, and they do indeed define its character. The 1.2 TSI manages 175MN, the same as a typical early ‘90s 2.0, but more amazingly this is all available from below 2000rpm, giving a very un-small feeling. The rapid changing DSG gearbox adds to the surrealness of the experience. In normal town driving the engine virtually never exceeds 2000rpm and there is really no need to. Full throttle will easily break the traction of the 215 16” tyres, on winter tyres you are limited to part throttle.  Very diesel-like, aside from the 6000rpm redline.
I bought this car remembering the small fun VWSA products of my youth, specifically the CitiGolf (Golf Mk1) and Polo Playa (Seat Ibiza Mk2). The Polo is small, light and powerful but comparatively so refined that a lot of the excitement is lost. Make no mistake, this can be a good thing, a 300kms trip was to be dreaded in a Golf 1, the Polo takes it in its stride.
But somehow you never get the same feeling driving it fast on small roads. Its utterly undramatic. The steering is electric, and while it has excellent feel compared to say, a Fabia or Clio, it doesn’t give you the detailed feedback that you need to become one with the car. The throttle response is best described as distant – you’re merely giving orders to engine room, not pulling the lever yourself – and the DSG7 gearbox is simply never in the right gear. Push down violently on the throttle and there is a delay, an embarrassing pause as if the ECU is asking itself “Did he mean to do that?”, come suddenly off the throttle, especially in Sport mode, and the engine will linger, roaring at high revs, as if caught out by your lack of consistency. This is all really a pity because on the odd occasion that you and the car get it all right, the power delivery is very impressive. So much torque, so little weight, and the gearbox holding the engine in its powerband – by small car standards seemingly endless acceleration. Compared to the almost amateurish behavior of the powertrain the handling is very polished. The damping is as good as it is reasonable to expect from a small, simply-sprung car, the compromise between roll control and comfort excellently chosen, the ride adequate despite 35 profile tyres. But it isn’t very interesting, the back simply follows the front, there is no adjustability, no subtlety to it. It’s amusing purely from how quickly you can move from point to point on country roads, with confidence and at speeds you would simply never match in most of its competition.
In winter however if’s a very different story. This is a car that relies on grip.  Without it there is abundant understeer which if you try to push through, as you can on some cars, you risk swinging out the tail or simply sliding sideways. Put simply the Polo does not cope well in conditions of low grip. It always feels skittish and unstable and any attempts to play are quickly interrupted by the typically-VAG overbearing ESP system.
For the keen driver then, and even more so someone with memories of small VWs of the past, this car is, and indeed has been to me, a disappointment. However to a normal sane person it is a great car. The quality of the interior is excellent , its an outstandingly easy and relaxing car to commute in, and it does around 6.0L per 100kms  (someone else can translate that into ridiculous MPG) even in heavy traffic. My lighter footed and more conscientious wife can easily achieve less than 5.5L per 100kms, in other words easily less than the real world figures for a wretched eco-diesel.